You're judging him which is the issue, seeing as you don't know him, weren't there, don't know anyone that was, you have no information other than what is pre-set in your head.You think I'm judging him harshly I don't think I am at all. I don’t know the guy, I don't have to accept his word.
Worse still you still hold this view following it being investigated by people who have spent time and deliberation over the matter. But no, your predigest is your compass, your predigest guides you.