Again, this is disingenuous BC because this is not what you are arguing when we keep hearing you 'youth watchers'.
No Todd. This is exactly what most, if not all of us are arguing, and has always been the core of my argument.
I am under no illusion that it is only very few academy kids that are even worth a chance, and that even then a tiny fraction of those will prove ultimately good enough to be viable squad use, and an even smaller fraction will end up as first team regular material.
But all I’m arguing is that we make better use of that free (kind of) resource , that doesn’t have to be world beaters at all to be viable and have some use to us as a squad, because very few of our purchases are even close to that standard and that we apply some of the same standards and criteria to them as to purchases, who also have a very small chance of being “world beaters” and rarely turn out to be.
Here’s a great example. Why the fuck has Mourinho given 60 minutes in central midfield to a 21yo who was failing to get a game for one of Portugal bully teams, and given 0 minutes to Oliver Skipp,who has proven to be a very competent midfielder on his limited chances.
And you frequently say that our academy players don’t deserve more chance if they don’t “shine” when they are given chances, so do you think Gedson’s 7 touches in 60 minutes means he should be done now? Or do you think he’ll still get more chances than Skipp. Did Onomah ever have an appearance where he averaged a touch every ten minutes ?
It took Aurier a year to learn how to take throw ins, and largely was atrocious every time he got a start, getting sent off, giving away penalties, costing us goals, why was he not judged after two games like KWP? It's taken him 3 seasons - and finally getting a consistent run of games - to start looking like a viable option - and he'll still never be a world beater, why do we not make similar allowances for the very exceptional academy player?
All most of us are arguing is for a more logical and sensible approach. We are pissing away resources. We aren't a club blessed with the resources of most of our main rivals.
We spend 12-14 years in many cases teaching and preparing footballers, they get picked internationally, win major international tournaments, play well in pre season games against good quality opposition, get minutes off the bench, get the odd cup start, and if they have made that stage (which is rare) and don't shit the bed at any of the numerous stages, then they are ready for the next test. The next test would normally be to go on loan and get regular proper football, or to be given more game time with our first team.
But under Poch this absolutely crucial next stage of development was largely removed, so a bunch of the most promising kids our academy has produced were not playing proper football at the most vital stage of their development. They weren't even playing U23 football any more. They were just put on ice.
And where players like Rose were allowed to cunt Poch, Levy, the club and fans off ion the media and still get picked, all Edwards had to do was be in a bit of a teenage huff to be deemed a lost cause.