You think overachieving in league in 5th? Not by much if at all tbh. We are the 4th biggest club by revenue. Yes we lost Kane, but we have signed/ effectively signed quite a number of good new players. I'd say we are about par on league performance given where Ange started from. Probably the best realistically we will finish now is 4th, which is a good performance.
I think it depends on if you're speaking with Lilywhite glasses on or not.
Before the season it was :
- City will win the league.
- Woolwich have strengthened a squad that came close to winning the league.
- Liverpool were an unknown quantity but still finished 3 places above us and had a net spend of close to 100m in the summer.
- Man Utd had finished 3rd, 15 points ahead of us and spent close to 200m in the summer...
- Aston Villa finished above us. Strengthened their squad and had a proven manager in place who had turned them around and put up MOTY numbers
- Newcastle were meant to go from strength to strength. Finished top four. Way ahead of us. Net spend of way over 100m in the summer.
That's 5 clubs there who, in the eye of many, were better positioned than us going into this season. Because in the summer all I heard was:
- We've just sold Harry Kane. We haven't got a replacement
- Ange is unproven
- Porro and Udogie can't play in a back four
- We should have signed Raya and not gone for the cheap option
- We should have signed Tapsoba and not gone for the cheap option
- Son is finished
- Our pre season wasn't good enough.
Not to mention all the protests in place before the season started.
So to even be where we are this season, on top of absolutely everything that happened in the summer, other teams around us and their expectations going into the season.
Id say yes, we have 100% over achieved THIS season league wise. It's probably a sad endictement of where we've fallen from a few years back when we should have been pushing on but that doesn't change the fact that going into this particular season, no one had us down to finishing in the top four and tbh even being in discussion. And if you did, fair play to you, you'll be happy with how it's going.