All of the above, if we're being objective about it.Pointing out that even when we’re good we are bad at winning trophies isn’t simping for the fucking dippers, get a grip.
It’s not even about them specifically. Take them out of the conversation and the reality is the same - 15 years of mostly being a top 4 challenging side and yet not even a league cup to show for it.
Why? Bad luck? Strategy? Mentality?
The CL Final is a prime example of this. A soft penalty was the bad luck, dropping Lucas for Kane was bad strategy, and the mentality suffered as a result.
The League Cup loss to Chelsea was pure bad strategy from Poch. Playing Son as a LWB? Even then, it took a Willian dive to get the pen. Bad luck somewhat, which compounded the bad strategy.
We've had a lot of opportunities to win Silverware under ENIC. For a number of reasons, we haven't quite got over the line. You can blame the board for lack of squad depth, but for nearly 2 seasons we were the biggest points gatherers in the PL under Poch, the problem was that it was spread over those 2 seasons, when the actual winners managed to concentrate their wins when it mattered over 1 season. Bad luck? Bad strategy? Bad mentality? I'd say it was a mixture of all of those.
The years since Poch have just been one bad strategy after another, but I feel that has been fixed now. I'd also suggest that the mentality, if not totally there, is well on the way to getting fixed. We can but hope that fixing the first 2 goes some way to fixing the third.