I'll maybe take the word of unbiased Villareal fans and to them he hasn't been anything special. I have watched him play some and he has not improved in the areas that concern me, maybe I have always caught him at his worst, but that is doubtful. Even today, doesn't look to have much, if any of a cross on him, still makes the major blunders in one on one duels, still puts himself out of position which means he has awkward situations to defend.
He was not close to MOTM today at all. maybe a 6/10.
The loan with the option to buy worked out he wasn't good enough for us went and found a place where he fits and now we get some money to spend on someone who is good enough. I don't see why when money is supposedly so tight that we would bring in a guy who isn't good enough and hope that he changes rather than brining in quality. It seems like the kind of move that has got us our current bloated squad full of back-ups that we really don't want starting for us.