Coming back to this thread a few days late, I see Martin Samuel was trying to take apart Dier for being chosen as England captain in the absence of others, cannot stand the odious bearded slug, he is exactly what is wrong with print journalists and their PFM opinions.
F365, perfectly take apart his utter garbage of an opinion...
Dier straits
If Mediawatch were to compile a list of the issues facing the English national team in the modern day, the general lack of enthusiasm, the proliferation of foreign players in the Premier League, the scarcity of chances for younger players, a lack of technical proficiency and the fact that we sometimes have to wear a blue kit would sit high. Samuel has spotted a far greater issue, however.
‘Eric Dier was asked about the 2014 World Cup,’ he begins. ‘What did he remember? “Not a lot, to be honest,” he stumbled. “I was in Portugal and my memories are not much. Who won?”‘
Thus begins one of the more bizarre articles on England in recent memory. The dismissive, scoffing nature of the next line – ‘Ladies and gentlemen, meet tonight’s England captain – confirms as such.
The article, sat beneath the headline ‘Dier proves ignorance is still bliss for England stars’, is based on the premise that Dier, who captains England against Germany on Friday evening, is indicative of the modern player, who doesn’t watch enough football.
‘This really isn’t about captaincy. It’s about football. When are we going to start producing players who actually watch the game; who feel there is worth in studying style and technique; who are engaged enough to want to observe great teams and great players via more than the fantasy world of a game console.’
Quite how Samuel gets from Dier’s initial response to an inane question to ‘kids nowadays play too much XStation 364 or Playbox One’ is astounding. As is the rest of the article, from which we have picked out a few choice lines:
‘Maybe Dier had a brain freeze in front of the cameras. Let’s hope. The alternative explanation is dismal indeed. That another generation of English footballers consider ignorance bliss.’
‘When does he plan to start paying attention; or is he just destined to make the same mistake as previous generations, like the one that got England knocked out against Uruguay?’
‘Our players come into matches like students who haven’t properly revised, wondering why they feel so nervous on exam day.’
‘The irony is that Dier should be one of our smartest footballers.’
All this from a throwaway response to a meaningless question, and the England hatchet job is already in full motion a full seven months before the World Cup begins.
Dier, for what it is worth, speaks both English and Portuguese, has been praised by Mauricio Pochettino for his tactical fluidity in being able to seamlessly transition between central defence and central midfield, and is widely considered as pretty intelligent. But because he was unable to enthusiastically share his memories of a tournament three years ago he is now accused of ‘not paying attention’, with the implication being that he is not a ‘smart footballer’.
Which true England fan or player can honestly pretend they have not tried to forget the 2014 World Cup?