From the Athletic.
The tension and frustration bubbled over on Thursday night as the Tottenham Hotspur players trudged back into the dressing room, 1-0 down to Liverpool at half-time.
Jose Mourinho was furious with the first-half defending, especially his team allowing Sadio Mane to run in behind and set up Roberto Firmino’s added-time tap-in, so Mourinho hauled off Serge Aurier, part of a double change designed to get Spurs back into the game.
Aurier himself was angry and hurt with Mourinho’s decision. He complained and the two men exchanged words. Things were heated. Aurier, pride wounded, stormed out of the Tottenham Hotspur Stadium and drove straight home.
Mourinho could have been forgiven for feeling frustrated that Tottenham’s crucial half-time break was wasted. This time was meant to prepare his team to switch from the 3-4-3 to a 4-2-3-1 system for the second half, to give them the best chance to get back into the game against the Premier League champions. Instead, half-time was dominated by this distracting row between the manager and one of his players.
As if to prove Mourinho’s point, Trent Alexander-Arnold scored Liverpool’s second goal two minutes after the resumption of the second half. Tottenham never truly got back into the match.
When Mourinho gave his press conference after the game, he was asked about the half-time row with Aurier. He confirmed that there was a sense of disappointment with how Tottenham were defending, without mentioning Aurier specifically.
“It is the mood of a team that is difficult to accept that you are losing,” Mourinho said. “It is difficult to accept the nature of the goal because the goal is, in some aspects, a replica of the first occasion that they had. So it is, of course, a mood where people are not happy. But then, we had to move.”
As the press conference went on, Mourinho made it increasingly clear who he has decided to blame for his team’s recent struggles. The same frustration that saw him replace Aurier at half-time was then turned on the rest of the defence in his comments to the media.
First, Mourinho had told BT Sport that it was “very, very hard to resist so many individual defensive mistakes”. Then, in his post-match press conference, he said it was a “performance totally affected by defensive individual mistakes”. The rest of the team was off the hook. He complimented them for being “totally in control”, he picked out Pierre-Emile Hojbjerg and Tanguy Ndombele for praise, but the defence was another matter.
When Mourinho was asked whether his defenders were simply not good enough, he decided not to answer the question. “The reality is you don’t need me to comment,” he said. “You watch the game. You can give many directions to your analysis.”
While the row Mourinho had with Aurier was a new turn for this season’s Spurs, the broader story of Mourinho going to war with his own defence is itself nothing new.
Two weeks ago, he reacted to the 1-1 draw with Fulham by pinning it on what he called “the characteristics of the players”, specifically his defenders, for conceding so many soft goals. Seeing Davinson Sanchez and Eric Dier torn apart by Fulham, you could understand Mourinho’s frustration,
even if you didn’t agree with him saying what he said.
With Mourinho, you always have to remember the strategy and politics behind the outbursts. There is always a purpose, a target he wants to provoke with his “confrontational leadership”, and sometimes, they still work:
the transformation of Ndombele since last March is proof of the power Mourinho still has to reach into his players and find a level of performance they could not find for themselves.
But if Mourinho hammering his own defence had really worked out, he would not have had to do it again late on Thursday evening. The fact that Mourinho has had to follow his post-Fulham criticisms with another set of stronger criticisms just two weeks later suggests that the first dose of medicine simply did not work. And it leaves Mourinho in a position familiar from his struggles at Chelsea and Manchester United in recent years: reaching for ever more powerful gestures and statements, hoping that the next one will have the shock impact that the last one missed out on.
The reality is that, whatever Mourinho’s frustrations with his defenders, they are not a bad set of players. The quartet of Toby Alderweireld, Dier, Sanchez and Joe Rodon is a good selection of senior centre-backs. Sergio Reguilon, Ben Davies, Aurier and Matt Doherty are a good stable of full-backs. These players have all achieved plenty in the game in recent years.
What Spurs need, clearly, is a defensive retrenchment in the next few weeks. This has been a pattern of Mourinho’s tenure so far: responding to bad results with solid defensive performances, going back to basics.
Last season, after the infamous 3-1 loss at Sheffield United in July, Spurs went back on the back foot to see out the end of the season. The 1-0 win over Everton and 0-0 draw at Bournemouth were almost unwatchable, but they were still clean sheets. Spurs won four and drew two of their last six games, conceding just three goals, securing sixth place in the league.
This season, after the disastrous 3-3 draw with West Ham in October, Spurs responded with a run of nine wins in 12 in all competitions, including eight clean sheets. They sat deeper, brought Alderweireld back in as a regular starter, and started to do the basics again.
All of this was achieved with the same defensive players that Mourinho has at his disposal now, and yet now the team only has one clean sheet in their last eight league games, a run dating from their exasperating 1-1 draw at Selhurst Park on December 13.
Maybe now is the time, going to Brighton on Sunday then hosting Chelsea next Thursday, for another defensive withdrawal, playing football more like what we saw earlier in the season, with Alderweireld at centre-back and Moussa Sissoko in midfield.
But it remains to be seen if and when Aurier will come back into the picture, and whether Spurs will have to stick with the struggling Doherty at right-back for the foreseeable future. On the other side, Reguilon has started well but is out for another three or four weeks, meaning that the overworked Davies will have to keep playing.
At centre-back, the one man guaranteed to face Brighton is Rodon, who made a mistake for the third Liverpool goal but still earned Mourinho’s praise. “The next game, he plays for sure,” Mourinho pointedly said on Thursday night. “He showed good personality, good concentration, and was good on the ball. He is not a coward. He is a brave boy to go for every duel, even against a difficult opponent.”
But Mourinho will have to do all of this, rebuilding a shaky defence, while also rebalancing the team in such a way to make up for
the loss of Harry Kane, Spurs’ best and most important player, for the next few games. Suddenly, it feels like the biggest challenge of his Tottenham tenure to date.