I share your assessment that he played and fought hard for the duration of his time on the pitch. Had I played in the same position, I doubt that anyone would say any different.
I also doubt that anyone would say that I had produced any kind of a threat, that I had played to premiership standards, had overloaded the oppositions defence with attacking threat, challenged the goons right back, or nullified his attacking potential. I also doubt that anyone would have said that I had ever put their keeper under any threat, apart from that of pissing himself laughing.
Had I played, I think everyone would have said that I worked my socks off for the whole game. I just doubt that anyone would have said that I was worth a damn.
Sigurdsson (by all accounts) had a great season last season with Swansea, but lets be honest. He was being let go by Hoffeheim - not Barcelona. On the back of a semi decent showing we took him off Liverpools hands for a figure that he has failed to justify.
He was workmanlike and ordinary today, and played one great ball all match.
In my opinion, it doesn't justify any great plaudits. If it toots your flute, then I really am happy for you.
I stand by my earlier statement, I would have been happier to see Holtby play the full game - certainly start in front of sigurdsson.
I dont really mind - or care, whether you, or anyone else sees it that way.