I agree about our midfield situation. We are lacking someone who can move the ball around and keep the opposition guessing. Parker is a good work-horse and committed defender, Mousa brings the ball forward well, has a few tricks and a decent shot on him and tracks back when he has to. But neither of them are genuine passing players, and we have been lacking that all season. Our team is filled with direct players who like to run at people and use their pace/dribbling to get behind them. This can work when there is actually space to run into, but when the opposition are well drilled defensively and close off all the gaps behind them, then our direct players are suddenly running into traffic and giving the ball away, or trying to have shots from a long way out. It's also an issue against teams who play really good possession football, meaning we can't a hold of the ball very often, and when we do manage to nick it we instantly try to run at them from deep positions and most likely lose the ball again as they close us down in numbers.
So I think we desperately need a natural passing player (or two) to allow us to quickly and accurately move the ball around to stretch the opposing defence and buy space for our runners, whether we are counter-attacking or trying to break down a resilient team. I was hoping that Tom Carroll would get a start against Everton, playing alongside Mousa and Scott in a midfield three. My thinking is that Parker would sit back as the holding player who primarily wins back possession and recycles it, Mousa would be the attacking one who primarily carries the ball forward and sometimes makes a run into the box, and Carroll would the roaming play-making one who zips the ball around either from deep position or from a modern number 10 position as needed. Obviously it wouldn't be quite that rigid, and there would be a lot of fluid movement and role reversals at times, but this is generally what I'm thinking could be a way forward for our midfield right now.
But regardless of that, I seriously think we need a major overhaul over the summer to bring in more natural ball players (i.e players who can pass the ball quickly and effortlessly, and can receive the ball in a congested area with a good first touch) and therefore speed up our possession game, cause for me that's the only way we can bridge the gap to the elite teams. You can't always rely on counter-attacking, dribbling past 4-5 defenders and/or wonder goals at the highest level of the game (although that counter-attacking ability is something we should maintain as part of our game); you also have to be able create chances from good possession in a more considered and effectively replicable way.