Don't get me wrong, I definitely want to win trophies. I just believe that focusing on cups is not a good thing.So your saying we should be happy with finishing top 4 every season, that what Woolwich use to do and look how it ended for them at lest they got a game cup here and there
We need to win something end off
The best team wins the league. The best team (usually) doesn't win the cup.
There is luck in the cup. All it takes is to have 1 bad half of football and you're out. Or you could play really well and just come up against a side playing out of its skin.
Look at the last few winners: Chelsea, Woolwich, ManU. None of them were great teams the year they won, they all finished outside the top 4.
Look at City breaking records last season, reaching 100 points. They went out in the 5th round vs Wigan. City had almost 85% possession and Wigan had only two shots at goal. City were playing a full strength team too (Aguero, Sane, Silva etc). And they still lost.
I want the team to win all cups they enter. But to me they are a dice roll and seasons should not be planned around them. Hopefully soon we can get in more depth which will turn the odds more in our favour. The only way that will happen is more top 4 finishes.
My ideal finish (apart from winning the league) is top 4 plus a cup. None of this hypothetical questions asking us to pick one or the other.